A skank fight in a Wendy’s- what next? A shivving at a Shoney’s? Not that I am trying to make the paragraph full of jokes, but I guess you can’t say this without invoking the Herman’s Hermits line, “Second verse, same as the first.” Like “Jump,” our director is Victor Nelli Jr and our writer is showrunner Silvio Horta. The only real change is saying goodbye to story editors Sarah Kucserka and Veronica West, replaced by Men in Trees and The Big C writer and producer, Cara DePaolo. While sadly we have Brian Tanen all season as staff writer, you know, the guy credited with writing the episode with sexual assault.

New season, new Betty, almost literally. Going back to where we were, we have Betty sat at her mother’s grave telling her (and us) that Betty told Henry to go suck eggs or himself, while she told Gio that if he doesn’t disappear, I’ll shoot him. Instead of “picking” a relationship, she’s finally picked herself, and she spent a while traveling like her mother wanted to do. Meanwhile, MODE is colder than hell as Wil-HEL(L)-mina is now running the place and replaced Daniel’s office with a nursery for the unborn baby. Claire is still running Hot Flash, and Alexis still runs Meade.

With Daniel out of the picture at Mode, he’s been given his own magazine, one that works more for his… little brain. It is also a playground for Daniel Jr (“DJ” for short), and it is where Betty will now be coming home to, metaphorically, as she’s still Daniel’s assistant, though he’s giving her more responsibility. Have I missed anything? Oh yeah, Papi got a job while Betty was away, and he now works for Kimmie Keegan, or more simply, model turned former Disney kid turned tabloid darling, Lindsay Lohan. Indeed, when the call came to have her recurring for a while in another Disney show, she was saying “Just My Luck.”

Sticking with a slightly revamped HD look from the end of season 2, we’re thrown right into it with Ugly Betty’s third and longest season on the books. It also means there is a larger change in production and the reason for some of the story changes too. Why no Henry? The whole production for Ugly Betty moved to New York to film on-location more, something last done in “Pilot.” The cast listing also changes with one of our major actors moving to recurring (we’ll get to that) and the new regular of Val Emmich from Vinyl, 30 Rock, and The Big C, playing Jesse.

Focusing back in on the episode itself though, Betty has finally found some agency for herself. In the time between seasons, Betty went off and traveled the lower 48 with lesbians in remission, and yes, that’s very much the implication with some lines that border on transphobia/homophobia about butch lesbians. The focus being on Betty’s time in San Francisco and the image of the woman representing a collective of what is implied as terminally ill women traveling due to a lapse in their illnesses, with Justin (of all) going in pretty hard, saying “THAT’s a woman?”

If memory serves me well, this isn’t the only “politically incorrect” set of lines we’ll continue to see throughout Ugly Betty. If the line is to showcase Justin being a bit more catty (albeit a stereotype), I don’t hate it and want to complain about it, but it is punching towards 50% butch lesbians and 50% punching towards implied breast cancer survivors. Again, punching down and punching sideways; alphabet Mafia-based violence is fine, but illness feels a bit much.

Shall we talk about the magazine instead? With a new lease on life and a new lease on a different floor of the Meade empire, Daniel has started up Player, a sex-driven magazine aimed at young men of the 2000s. Albeit without the actual sex bit because the show is on ABC, not HBO. I don’t want to get too into it, but it feels like a regression of Daniel’s progress since season 1. I get why we’re doing this and doing it this way, but there is a lot of bloat on this whole Player storyline that I think could have been handled a bit better.

Putting aside the fact that Daniel is wearing a tracksuit that almost makes him look as unapproachable as a 70s BBC children’s TV presenter (that’s dark), the whole thing screams a broad appeal/catch-all stereotype of hetero male “culture.” There isn’t really a comment on it as much as there is with MODE because of how short-lived this is, but there is this antagonistic-like feeling around it to Betty. The whole place smells of cheap body sprays, suspect meat, and premature receding hairlines. A teenager’s paradise, in theory.

I make it no secret that the whole Player storyline doesn’t excite me for that story itself. It is more so the storylines that come after that matter to me. As I noted during the “Jump” piece, seasons 3 and 4 are aiming to be more mature-based for Betty getting ahead in her career. To quote Horta, “I think we started to veer a little too much into the romantic storyline.” Not that we’re fully done with them, as we’ll see, but there is now a focus on work itself.

The struggle, now, is more about how you can work somewhere while a small French teenager is allowed to run roughshod. I am jumping ahead a little and not spreading out the storylines, but that’s because it isn’t really an episode about this. It all culminates in two flashpoints: At a Harley show (whatever that is) Player is unveiling ‘The Biker Chicks of Player,’ where DJ messes with a model, so she refuses to ride, and Betty takes over; DJ sprays silly string in her face moments before she rides off, sending her through a gazebo with bikini-clad women play-fighting in a makeshift pool of Kool-Aid.

I don’t think I’ve found anything less attractive than “a gazebo with bikini-clad women play-fighting in a makeshift pool of Kool-Aid.” If that’s not enough to have the chancla thrown at him, DJ later covers his closet relative’s silk dress with chocolate. As much as the Player storyline is set up as an antagonist of Betty’s goals, it is also set up to show that Daniel hasn’t been an authority in Daniel Jr’s life; he’s been the enabler. The hot models and skimpy outfits are the thing they bond on, so he tried to get close to DJ.

The actual crux of the episode is Betty and this apartment with the next-door couple of 48 years and their nudist habits. It is a terrible apartment. The first one she sees is great; it is colorful, it is nice, it has alright views, and perfect, but when it is re-dressed to be a secondary option after someone gets the nice one, it is a serial killer’s paradise. It is dark, dingy, the roof is leaking (it’s the top floor), and did I mention the OAP nudists? It is what realtors call, when they are BSing, a “fixer-upper.”

A bit of paint, a crime scene clean-up crew, and some furniture— oh, and curtains to keep the nudists out– it will look fine. Maybe a plumber or someone to fix the leak. It is all to set up that our Betty is now setting herself up as independent. A maturity that the show desperately needs after the Gio-Henry-Henry-Gio thing. We’ve got the first step of the show righting itself; it just needs to get away from Player, and we can progress with Betty from there.

I’ll also finally say her name since I didn’t last time out. Lindsey Lohan. The other thing we’re setting up for this season is the Kimmie Keegan stuff, with Papi now working at an off-brand fast-food burger joint; his boss is Betty’s high school tormentor. Something Kimmie is all too pleased to find out before firing the old man, resulting in the opening line, “a skank fight in a Wendy’s.” Again, right now, it is a nothing storyline: We’re setting up for the season as a whole.

I don’t really have problems with “The Manhattan Project,” aside from the fact that it killed almost a quarter of a million people. It is a fine, so-so episode to set things up, but it can be heavy-handed and a bit too slow at getting to the actual point. So much so that next time we’re finishing off what could have been done here. That said, I don’t know what you’d cut or change about it either: The DJ bit is just a bit annoying, Player is setting up a MODE return (spoiler), and Kimmie is setting up the Lindsey Lohan stuff.

Ultimately, “The Manhattan Project” is fine and memorable, but not memorable distinctly for being good itself. Metaphorically, it puts all of the puzzle pieces on the coffee table, but some of them are upside down, and many of them are scrambled. I don’t like saying it because it sounds too mechanical, but it is very much a functional episode that gets us to where we need to be to move forward. The only good, memorable scene is when Wilhelmina is looking into Daniel’s old office after the construction workers put a hole in the wall.

Phenixx Gaming is everywhere you are. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter, Bluesky, and Instagram.

Also, if you’d like to join the Phenixx Gaming team, check out our recruitment article for details on working with us.

Phenixx Gaming is proud to be a Humble Partner! Purchases made through our affiliate links support our writers and charity!

Ugly Betty "The Manhattan Project"

6.5

Score

6.5/10

Pros

  • A lot of setup for a fun season of madness.
  • The man-whores are gone.
  • She's finally got THE apartment.

Cons

  • Did we need the mildly transphobic line about the lesbians in remission?
  • I think the DJ stuff could have been a bit better.

Discover more from Phenixx Gaming

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

avatar

Keiran McEwen

Keiran Mcewen is a proficient musician, writer, and games journalist. With almost twenty years of gaming behind him, he holds an encyclopedia-like knowledge of over games, tv, music, and movies.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.